Two private tasting parties yielded a great weekend beer list! Some of the things we pulled out were pretty amazing, and our party hosts provided an outstanding setting for tasting.
On Friday night, a small group of us gathered to share growlers. Hops were out in full force to make up this list.
We started with Rock Bottom Sub Zero IPA, which Ffej and Brandi picked up earlier in the day at King of Prussia. It’s a Simcoe-hop-based IPA, and had a really nice balance of piney and citrusy hop flavors. As one of the Brewmaster’s specials, it doesn’t appear on the website, but reviews can be read at Beer Advocate.
Next it was Pure Hoppiness from Alpine Beer Company. Alpine uses hops in the boil, runs it through a hopback, and also dry-hops this Double IPA. This was a brighter, sweeter IPA. Both Ffej and D mentioned tropical and citrus fruit overtones; I thought the pine-sap sweetness and light malt flavors were in perfect harmony.
For our third offering, we opened a growler of Surly Grit 16. This is a Double IPA which was released as a growler-only special in recognition of loyal customers during the last days in which Surly was allowed to sell growlers due to current MN law. (In 2008, Surly sold over 3500 barrels of beer; MN law only allows off-sale licenses for breweries producing less than 3500 barrels. They can’t get the license in 2009 without cutting production, so no more growler sales, no more Darkness Day, and no more SurlyFest until/unless the law is changed.)
30 bbls of 16 Grit were brewed, but a couple were sucked up during the dry-hopping process. 901 growlers were sold on the first day. 16 Grit was kettle hopped with Warrior, Amarillo and Glacier hops, then dry-hopped twice with Glacier and Amarillo. It came out to 9% ABV (110 IBUs), and the folks at Surly described it as well balanced, caramel-oat malt flavors and huge orange lemon aroma finishing with a pithy bitterness.
D and I had a growler lined up for ourselves, but it slipped away. Luckily, Dain was able to score one and kind enough to share it. (There is a video of someone – not us – enjoying a growler…it picks up after minute #2.) It was a real treat just to get a glass.
Finally, we had Hopsickle Triple IPA from Moylan’s, which D picked up in a swingtopbottle. Brewed withTomahawk, Cascade and Centennial hops, this is a potent beverage with incredible hop stickiness.
I must make a special note here to say that we were pleased to see Troeg’s Nugget Nectar on tap at The Old Corner Hotel in Williamsport on Saturday night. Unfortunately, the staff there don’t seem to know what a great beer they’ve got (it doesn’t even have a unique tap handle.) But we did!
Our friends David and Sarah hosted a Sunday stout tasting as an opportunity to clear out their beer cellar a little bit. It was a really fun event because they organized the afternoon as a blind tasting. We started with the line-up of five Coffee Stouts and one lone doppelbock, followed by 16 Imperial Stouts. I know this sounds like a lot, but the servings were very small with such a nice group of people doing the tasting.
David masked the bottles well, and poured a small amount for each person, and then we were asked to rate the beer on a scale of 1 to 10, as well as name the beer (it was a multiple choice test.) What an interesting experiment – a test of our own senses and perceptions. When the real names of the beers were revealed at the end, many of us were surprised at our guesses as well as our ratings.
Finally, the scores were averaged, and we were all sent a copy of the scored results. Here they are, scored from highest to lowest:
- Mikkeller Beer Geek Breakfast (1st bottling); Overall score of 7.73
- Pisgah Valdez; Overall score of 7.5
- Brasserie Dieu Du Ciel Péché Mortel; Overall score of 7.32
- Alesmith Speedway Stout; Overall score of 7.08
- Ithaca Kaffinator; Overall score of 6.7
- Deschutes Black Butte XX; Overall score of 6.25
- Mikkeller Black Hole; Overall score of 4.93
- Goose Island Bourbon County Stout 2008 ;Overall Score of 9.0
- Foothills Sexual Chocolate; Overall score of 7.63
- Amager Bryghus Hr. Frederiksen; Overall score of 7.44
- (tie) Hoppin’ Frog B.O.R.I.S. The Crusher Oatmeal-Imperial Stout (2007); Overall score of 7.08 and Pennichuck Pozharnik Whiskey Barrel Aged Brewers Reserve; Overall score of 7.08 (more higher marks)
- Three Floyds Dark Lord (2007); Overall score of 7.04
- (tie) Stone Imperial Russian Stout 2008 Overall score of 7.0 and Deschutes The Abyss (2006); Overall score of 7.0 (more higher marks)
- Stone 12th Anniversary Bitter Chocolate Oatmeal Stout; Overall score of 6.73
- (tie) Stoudt’s Barrel Aged Fat Dog (2008 whiskey); Overall score of 6.54 and Oskar Blues Ten FIDY; Overall score of 6.54 (more higher marks)
- Left Hand Imperial Stout; Overall score of 6.42
- Highland Imperial Black Mocha Stout; Overall score of 6.23
- Odell Imperial Stout; Overall score of 6.12
- Great Divide Oak Aged Yeti Imperial Stout (2007); Overall score of 6.08
- Brooklyn Black Chocolate Stout 2008 Overall score of 6.0
At some point I may go back and add links to these, but it’s another one of those nights where I stayed up too late.
Many, many thanks to our hosts for providing such a nice selection of beers, an interesting event and great food and coffee (fresh from Costa Rica!)